Under the Silver Lake — A dreamlike haze over a mystery
The film balances surreal tone with real tension, but its ambition outpaces its coherence. The central mystery remains oddly distant from the characters' emotional stakes.
Text size
Spoiler-free review.
A strange melancholy lingers in every frame, even during moments of violence or revelation. The protagonist's search for his missing neighbor becomes a journey through Los Angeles's underbelly, but the stakes feel unevenly weighted. David Robert Mitchell crafts an atmosphere that is more mood than narrative, sometimes at the expense of clarity.
The dialogue doesn't always match the film's tone, feeling like it belongs to a different story. Andrew Garfield gives a sincere performance, even when the script doesn't give him much to work with. Riley Keough and Topher Grace add some mystery but rarely tie into the main character's drive.
The pacing shifts unpredictably between languid exploration and sudden bursts of action. This inconsistency makes it hard to invest in the central mystery or its resolution. The film’s visual style is striking, yet it often obscures rather than enhances the emotional truth.
The film tries to explore ideas about identity and loneliness, but they don't get much attention. The dialogue sometimes feels too clever for its own good, without really paying off. Still, the film's embrace of uncertainty keeps it from being completely forgettable.
2018 · English. Film details · Poster source · Artwork © its respective rights holders.
7/10
My verdictThe film balances surreal tone with real tension, but its ambition outpaces its coherence. The central mystery remains oddly distant from the characters' emotional stakes.
— Desly